I signed on as a client with eLove and Cupid's Coach in December of 2011 and it's been a very positive experience -- I've met three men thus far and they've all been appropriate introductions. I've had second dates with two of them and one I've got a third date scheduled for this coming weekend with the one who's my favorite.
Pros
Professional, service oriented matchmakers and dating coaches, responsive, caring, sincere. They're good people.
Cons
None really. It's not inexpensive to hire a matchmaker, but it's so much more effective than online dating, which to me was far too random.
Visit eLove Reviews about eLove